Migrating from Mailchimp to Kit or Beehiiv
How to move your email list and automations from Mailchimp to Kit (formerly ConvertKit) or Beehiiv: export and import steps, what transfers, and what to set up fresh.
Mailchimp is where many businesses start with email marketing. It's well known and has a free plan to get going on. But as your list and needs grow, you may decide another tool fits how you actually work: the automations you want, what it costs at your list size, or how your emails perform. Kit (formerly ConvertKit) and Beehiiv are two popular alternatives.
The good news: your subscriber list is portable. You own it and you can take it with you.
What transfers and what doesn't
What you can migrate
- Subscriber email addresses
- Subscriber first and last names
- Custom fields (matched to fields in the new platform during the import)
- Tags: Kit's Mailchimp importer builds tags from your list names, Mailchimp tags and interest groups; with a CSV you map a tag column yourself
- Your domain sender identity (set up fresh)
What must be rebuilt
- Email templates and designs
- Automation sequences (welcome series, drip campaigns)
- Saved segments, unless Kit's own migration team moves them for you (the tags behind them come across either way)
- Landing pages
- Sign-up forms
- Integrations with your website
An unsubscribe follows the person, not the platform
Someone who opted out of your list has opted out of your emails, whichever tool you send them from. In the US, the FTC's CAN-SPAM guidance says you must honor an opt-out request within 10 business days; Canada's CASL and Europe's GDPR both rest on having the person's consent in the first place.
The safe way to handle this in a migration is not to bring those people over at all. Import only your subscribed contacts, and keep the unsubscribed list as your own record so you can prove someone opted out. This is general guidance, not legal advice. Check with your own adviser if you're unsure.
Step 1: Export your Mailchimp list
Log in to Mailchimp as an Owner or Admin. Mailchimp only lets those two user levels export an audience, so check your access before migration day.
Export your audience. Click Audience, pick the audience if you have more than one, then click Export audience. In the "Export all contacts?" pop-up, click Export CSV. Mailchimp processes the export in the background and emails you when it's ready. It isn't an instant download.
Open the export and note the separate files. The download may be a ZIP containing one CSV per contact type: subscribed, unsubscribed, non-subscribed and cleaned. You only import the subscribed file. Keep the rest as your own record. Download promptly: Mailchimp keeps an export available in your account for 30 days.
Document your automations. Take screenshots or notes on every automation sequence: the trigger, the delay, the email content. You'll rebuild these in the new platform.
Step 2: Choosing between Kit and Beehiiv
Help me choose
Kit or Beehiiv?
Kit is designed for creators, coaches, and businesses that rely on email automation. Its visual automation builder, email sequences and tag-based segmentation are its strengths. Kit also includes a migration with every paid plan: its team moves your subscribers, tags, lists and segments, and for accounts with 10,000 subscribers or more it also rebuilds your forms, email templates, automation emails and integrations. Check with Kit what your own account covers before you plan the work.
Best for: Businesses with complex automations, product launches, or course/coaching funnels.
Pricing: There's a free plan, but it covers forms, landing pages, broadcasts and tagging, the visual automations, email sequences and app integrations sit on the paid plans, which are priced by subscriber count. Check kit.com/pricing for the current plans and limits.
Step 3: Import your subscribers to the new platform
Create your Kit account at kit.com if you haven't already.
Open the Mailchimp importer. Go to the Subscribers page, click Add Subscribers, then Other provider, then pick Mailchimp.
Give Kit your Mailchimp API key. Kit then syncs your Mailchimp contacts and their data across for you. You don't have to upload a CSV. If you'd rather use the CSV you already exported, Kit accepts that too.
Check the tags Kit created. The importer builds tags from your Mailchimp list names, your existing Mailchimp tags, and your list-and-interest combinations: a "Newsletter" list with a "Tech" interest group becomes a Newsletter:Tech tag. Review them before you send anything.
Leave your unsubscribed contacts behind. Import only the subscribed contacts. Don't upload the unsubscribed CSV from your Mailchimp export.
Kit's terminology differs from Mailchimp's, which trips people up: a Mailchimp contact is a Kit subscriber, an audience is Kit's single list, a regular email is a broadcast, an automated series is an email sequence, and a customer journey or classic automation becomes a visual automation.
Step 4: Set up your sender identity
Both Kit and Beehiiv let you authenticate your own sending domain, and you should. This means adding DNS records to your domain to prove that you own it and are authorized to send email from it. Skip it and your emails are far more likely to be treated as spam.
Follow the platform's domain authentication steps. Both Kit and Beehiiv provide step-by-step instructions in their settings panels under domain or sender authentication.
Add the required DNS records. These include SPF, DKIM, and sometimes DMARC records. See email DNS records for an explanation of what these are.
Verify the records. After adding the DNS records, use the platform's verify or check button. A new record usually shows up within minutes, but it can take longer: how long depends on your DNS provider and the record's TTL. See DNS propagation if it doesn't verify straight away.
Step 5: Rebuild automations and templates
Your email templates and automation sequences need to be rebuilt. Kit's own migration guide describes this as recreating them by hand (copying the content across and setting up the schedules again) rather than importing them, and Beehiiv's guidance for bringing old content over is the same copy-and-paste approach. The exception is Kit's assisted migration for larger accounts, which rebuilds them for you (see Step 2).
Use your screenshots and notes from Step 1 as the reference. Recreate your:
- Welcome email sequence
- Any drip campaigns or nurture sequences
- Re-engagement automations
- Product or service announcement templates
Step 6: Update your sign-up forms
Your website forms that were connected to Mailchimp need to be updated or replaced with new forms pointing to Kit or Beehiiv.
- If you used embedded Mailchimp forms, replace them with the new platform's embedded form code
- If you used a WordPress plugin (like WPForms with a Mailchimp integration), update the plugin's settings to connect to the new platform instead
- If you used landing pages hosted on Mailchimp, recreate them in the new platform or on your website
When to send your first email on the new platform
Don't send a mass email on your first day in the new platform. Start with a small segment to check deliverability and confirm everything is configured correctly. A new sending domain takes time to build reputation, sending slowly at first (a few hundred emails, then increasing) is better than sending to your entire list on day one.
Common questions
Will my subscribers know I changed platforms?
No. Subscribers receive email from your domain name (e.g. newsletters@yourbusiness.com), not from Mailchimp's or Kit's servers directly. As long as your sender address stays the same, subscribers won't notice the platform change.
Can I keep my Mailchimp account while migrating?
Yes, and you should. Keep Mailchimp active until the new platform is fully set up, your automations are rebuilt, and you've sent a few test campaigns successfully. Cancel Mailchimp only after you're confident the new platform is working correctly.
What about existing subscribers who signed up via a Mailchimp landing page?
If you have Mailchimp-hosted landing pages driving sign-ups, update or replace those landing pages before cancelling Mailchimp. If you cancel Mailchimp first, those pages stop working and you lose new subscribers.
Will my open rates and click stats transfer?
No. Mailchimp's contact export leaves out report data like open and click rates. You export those separately, as an email report. The imports on the other side only cover subscriber records, custom fields and tags, so you start fresh with engagement data in the new platform. Export the reports you care about while your Mailchimp account is still active.
Related guides
Learn more
Was this page helpful?
Go deeper on chykalophia.com
Talk it through
Want a second pair of eyes on this?
Book a free discovery call, up to an hour. Bring the question you're stuck on and we'll tell you honestly what we'd do.
Already a client? Email support@chykalophia.com.
Last updated